SOBBING: OSCAR PISTORIUS CLUTCHES ROSARY BEADS IN THE DOCK AS DOCTOR TELLS OF HARROWING MOMENT HE TRIED TO SAVE REEVA
Oscar Pistorius wept in the dock
today as a neighbour described the harrowing moment he tried to resuscitate his
girlfriend after she was shot.
Radiologist Johan Stipp dashed to
the Paralympian's home after hearing gunshots to find Pistorius kneeling next
to Reeva Steenkamp and 'praying to God' that she would survive, the trial
heard.
He said: 'At the bottom of the
stairs... there was a lady lying on her back on the floor. It was obvious that
she was mortally wounded.
'I went near her and, as I bent
down, I also noticed a man on the left kneeling by her side. He had his left
hand on her right groin, and his right hand, the second and third fingers in
her mouth.
'I remember the first thing he said
when I got there was "I shot her. I thought she was a burglar. I shot
her".'
As he gave his testimony, Pistorius bent forward in the dock and put his hand over his face while clutching rosary beads on what was the 12th anniversary of his mother's death.
He then moved his hands to cover
both ears.
The dramatic evidence by Dr Stipp
was the first detailed public description of the immediate aftermath of the
shooting of Miss Steenkamp on Valentine's day last year.
Oscar, crying at the trial |
Dr Stipp, who said he didn't know who Pistorius was until later, said he tried to help, but Miss Steenkamp showed no signs of life.
He said he noticed a wound in her
right thigh, in her upper arm and in the right side of the head and there was
brain tissue around the skull.
He said: 'She had no pulse in the
neck, she had no peripheral pulse. She had no breathing movements that she
made.
'Oscar was crying all the time,' he said. 'He was praying to God, saying "Please let her live".
'Oscar said he would dedicate
"his life and her life to God" if she would live and not die that
night.'
Earlier, Pistorius's lawyer claimed
neighbours could not possibly have heard a woman's screams the night he shot
his girlfriend because she was inside a locked bathroom.
On a second day of fierce
cross-examination, lawyer Barry Roux attacked witness Charl Johnson's assertion
that he heard screaming and gunshots when Reeva Steenkamp was killed.
Mr Roux said: 'At the time you heard
the deceased, she was in a locked bathroom.
'The deceased was in the toilet and
the door was locked. Even standing on the balcony, it would have been
impossible to hear the screams.'
Mr Roux says the banging sounds were actually Pistorius hitting a toilet door with a bat and the screaming was the distressed athlete calling for help.
Mr Johnson said he 'disputed' some
of what Mr Roux was saying and described in more detail what he heard on the
night Pistorius shot his girlfriend to death.
He said: 'The fear in the lady
person's calls contrasted with a very monotone male voice. The man almost
sounded embarrassed to be calling for help.'
Yesterday, Mr Roux lawyer had sought
to undermine the testimony of Mr Johnson and his wife Michell Burger, saying
similarities in their accounts indicated they had aligned their versions at the
expense of the truth.
He said there were differences
between the statements that they had given to police after the shooting and
testimony they had given in court.
Both the statements and the
testimony shared similarities, Mr Roux said, implying that the couple had
contaminated their evidence by talking through what they were going to say.
'You could just as well have stood
together in the witness box,' he said during cross-examination on the third day
of the trial. 'What do you say to that?'
The tart assertion drew a caution
from Judge Thokozile Masipa, who told Roux he had gone too far.
Roux contended that crucial elements
in the testimony of the couple were missing in their earlier comments to
police.
This included the statements that
they heard a woman's screams rising in anxiety and intensity and that they
heard the woman's voice 'fading' after the last in a volley of gunshots.
Mr Johnson suggested that he and his
wife were more expressive while testifying in court than when providing
information for a police document.
'I would venture a guess that it's
the way you verbally tell the story,' he said.
'There's a lot more emotion
involved... whereas the statement is more factual.'
Mr Roux later said that telephone records will show that the banging sounds the neighbors heard were actually a distressed Pistorius hitting a toilet door with a cricket bat after realising he had shot Miss Steenkamp.
Mr Roux says call records will show
Pistorius called an estate manager at around 3.19am soon after he bashed in the
door with the bat.
In Johnson and Burger's testimony,
they say they heard what they described as shots straight after making a call
to security at 3.16 am.
The similar times show the sounds
were the bat on the door, Roux argued.
'There is only one thing you could
have heard, because it coincides precisely,' Mr Roux said to Johnson. '
That was the time that he
(Pistorius) broke down the door (with the bat).'
Johnson replied, addressing the
judge: 'My lady, I am convinced the sound I heard was gunshots.'
'I understand,' Roux said in the
exchange, suggesting Johnson had convinced himself they were shots.
Throwing doubt on the their recollection of the sequence is crucial for Pistorius's defense after the state maintained there was a loud argument on the night he shot Steenkamp through a door in his bathroom and screams and shouts before a gun was fired.
Pistorius's team wants to show the
screams were Pistorius calling for help after the accidental shots.
Before giving his testimony, Mr
Johnson had earlier told how he has been inundated with abusive phone calls
from the athlete's supporters after his mobile number was read out in court.
Charl Johnson told the judge he
received one 'intimidating' voicemail which said: 'Why are you lying in court?
You know Oscar didn't kill Reeva. It's not cool.'
He said he has been forced to switch
off his phone after receiving so many calls which he said was a breach of his
privacy.
He told the court: 'It keeps on
ringing so I keep it off. I feel my privacy has been compromised severely.'
His phone number was read out in
court by Pistorius's lawyer Barry Roux yesterday, but Mr Johnson said he wasn't
aware of this because he was sat in the witness room.
After a break, prosecutor Gerrie Nel
asked for permission to stand down Mr Johnson to get more records.
The judge agreed and the case moved
on to its fourth witness, the South African boxer and friend of Pistorius,
Kevin Lerena.
Mr Lerena told the trial how
Pistorius asked a friend to take the blame after he accidentally discharged a
pistol under the table of a Johannesburg restaurant a month before he killed
his girlfriend.
Testifying for the prosecution
against the South African Olympic and Paralympic track star, professional boxer
Kevin Lerena described how he, Pistorius and two others had been having dinner
at Tashas restaurant when the gun went off.
Lerena said one of the group, Darren
Fresco, passed his pistol under the table to Pistorius, telling him there was
'one up' - an indication that a round was loaded in the chamber.
Mr Lerena said: 'A shot went off.
Then there was just compelte silence.
'I looked down at the floor and
exactly where I looked down, where my foot was, there was a hole in the floor.
I had a little graze on my toe, but I wasn't hurt.'
Pistorius immediately apologised to
his fellow diners and checked they had not been hurt, but then turned to Mr
Fresco and asked him to take responsibility, Lerena said, testifying on the
third day of Pistorius' murder trial in Pretoria.
Mr Lerena quoted Pistorius as saying:
'Please take the blame for me - there's too much media hype around me'.
He added: 'When the restaurant
owners came up, Darren took the blame.'
Lerena, who goes by the ring name of
KO Kid, was giving evidence in relation to a lesser charge brought against
Pistorius of discharging a weapon in a public place.
The prosecution has sought to
portray the 27-year-old athlete, known as Blade Runner, as gun-obsessed.
Comments
Post a Comment